L: Review of Art Spiegelman’s “Maus” and “Maus II”

Click here for IMDB

Click here for IMDB

I watched a movie the other night called “People, Places, Things” mostly because Jemaine Clement starred in it and I will follow him to the ends of this Earth. I was pleasantly surprised, however, when Jemaine’s character drew comics and taught a class on the ways graphic stories can convey important messages to readers. He also argued the importance of adding graphic novels to the texts discussed in college-level Literature classes and that the genre’s absence from Literature classes keeps its stories from being perceived as a legitimate form of literature. The presence of these elements of what I assumed would be a typical romantic comedy took me by surprise since just last week I read my first graphic novel and immediately saw the value of adding it to a classroom setting.

Click here for Goodreads

Click here for Goodreads

Every person learns differently. Every person has different interests and skills that can affect the way that they intake information, or fail to do so. I, for one, am a very visual learner. I can hear something all day long and I’ll absorb it as well as possible, but when I see something, not visualize but physically see it, my ability to retain that information is increased tenfold. Herein lies arguably the most valuable feature of the graphic novel. Not only am I reading the author’s words, but I’m unmistakably seeing what (s)he intended for me to see. Now, some may argue that this removes the reader’s ability to use their imagination to formulate the images, but I say poo-poo to that argument. Sometimes, the author needs to convey messages that may be beyond the reader’s imagination, or at least outside of what readers may be comfortable picturing. Such was the case with Art Spiegelman’s graphic novels, Maus and Maus II.

Click here for Goodreads

Click here for Goodreads

The stories are told from the perspective of Art who is telling the story of his father, Vladek Spiegelman’s, experiences during World War II and the Holocaust. Understanding the horrific magnitude of Vladek’s memories would be visceral and disturbing enough if told in a standard, narrative novel format, but the use of images to support the story and offer visual perspective elevates the level of understanding and thereby disbelief at the atrocities recounted in the stories. Through my reading experience, I repeatedly noted that in order for these novels to be incorporated into a high school classroom, I would have to ensure that my students were mature enough to digest the information appropriately, or simply limit their exposure to the most graphic parts by only reading excerpts instead of the whole. However, I don’t wish to do that in my classroom. The fact that these things are hard to read does not in any way mean that they should not be read, and we do not reverse the course of history by veiling the truth. The truth deserves to be told, and I wouldn’t hesitate to incorporate these graphic novels into a WWII or Holocaust-focused lesson.

These novels have a story to tell and, if one can only set aside any preconceived ideas about the maturity or age level of “comics,” you could truly learn something from them. I highly recommend them.

Advertisements

4 Comments

Filed under Book Review, Lindsay

4 responses to “L: Review of Art Spiegelman’s “Maus” and “Maus II”

  1. Pingback: “Keep It Fresh” Award | Untamed Shrews

  2. Pingback: L: Review of Noelle Stevenson’s “Nimona” | Untamed Shrews

  3. Poo-poo, indeed! (I just really wanted to say poo-poo too.)
    I think Maus I & II were the first graphic novels I ever read and I did so in high school. Everyone imagines stories differently and I think graphic novels help the reader to see exactly what the author wants them to see. Plus, if it’s something gruesome, then it’s much more shocking seeing it than imagining it.
    I started reading more graphic novels and comics this year so I hope to read more graphic memoirs soon as well. I heard Persepolis is a good one.

    • Oh for sure! I totally agree, seeing things as the author intends really makes some works more powerful. I’ve heard amazing things about Persepolis, March, Blankets, American Born Chinese, and Nimona. Now if I can just find time for them… 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s